Both the cases of Tom Robinson from the book to kill a mockingbird, and Emmett Till were judged in front of an all white all male jury and they both lost. There were a lot of similarities in the cases the white people got away with what they did. Emmett Till was murdered after he was dared to talk to a white woman and her husband, Roy Bryant ,and his half brother, J.W. Milam kidnaped and beat Till and finally killed him. Tom Robinson was accused of raping a white girl. The two cases are different in the benging but similar at the same time After Till was murdered Roy Bryant and J.W. Milam were put on trial in front of an all white all male jury and at the time most everyone hated the blacks just because they were black. So Bryant and Milam
In the Story To Kill a Mockingbird, Tom Robinson, an African American is blamed and killed for something that was not his fault and had nothing to do with. But in the report of Emmett Till he was killed for something that he did do. So there are a couple of things that i can Compare and contrast about Tom Robinson and Emmett till and why they both suffered the same “consequences” Tom Robinson was accused of the rape and beating of Mayella ewell even though it was obvious That Bob Ewell was the one who beat her, And Emmett Till was killed because he he “Harassed” a white woman that was married because he’s friends told him to do it. Some of the things that we can contrast about them is that Tom Robinson was NOT the one who “Raped” and “Beat”
I am going to compare Tom and Till, for their murders and what had happen to them and the same reasons. They were both killed in the south after the civil war. They were also black. Tom was killed because they thought they he had raped they white women.
Two men named Roy Bryant and J.W. Milam were charged for the murder of Emmett Till after a statement from Moses “Preacher” Wright. Which was that these two men had come to his house to take him away. Due to the horrible
W. Kellum told the jury today that ‘your forefathers will turn over in their graves’’ if they convicted two white men of murdering a 14-year-old Chicago negro boy.” (Kolin)This quote proves that the defense had told the jury to make sure that they come to a verdict of not guilty. The outcome of the trial was clearly fixed, for example, “A fourteen-year-old boy, Emmett Till, had been brutally murdered and his body thrown into the Tallahatchie River, but despite clear evidence that two white men committed the crime, an all-white jury returned a "Not Guilty" verdict after just an hour of deliberation.” (Linder Background)This quote proves that the jury was very inclined to reach the verdict of not guilty just because Bryant and Milam are white. The outcome of the trial helped was a major factor leading to the civil rights movement, according to Douglas Linder, “The trial of Roy Bryant and J. W. Milam for the murder of Till shook the conscience of a nation and helped spark the movement for civil rights for black Americans.”
On the day of August 24, 1955, 14 year old Emmett Till was on vacation to Money, Mississippi when he was murdered because he was flirting with a white woman. He was killed by the woman’s husband and her brother. The murderers made him carry a 75 pound cotton gin to the banks of the Tallahatchie River, where he was forced to take off his clothes, and was beaten to death, had an eye gouged out, shot in the head, and then tied to the cotton gin with barbed wire. He was then thrown into the river to die. Till grew up in a working class neighborhood south of Chicago, and he went to a segregated school, but he wasn’t ready for the segregation he would face in Mississippi.
The abduction, torture, and murder of Emmett "Bobo" Till in August of 1955 was a major turning point in history that motivated the [African-American] Civil Rights Movement. When the accused, half-brothers Roy Bryant and J. W. Milam were tried and acquitted of all charges, this caused uproar in the African-American community. There were several factors that contributed to the outcome of the case, such as gender, class, and ethnicity. These factors and several others will be discussed throughout this essay. BACKGROUND OF EMMETT TILL Emmett Louis
The murder of Emmett Till was a day that no one will ever forget it was the most horrific murder of all time. July 25, 1941 Emmett Louis Till was born Emmett was raised in a nice middle class neighborhood in the southside of Chicago, Illinois being raised by a single mother after his father Louis Till was hung in the army after being accused of rape and a killing. Emmett Till attended Mccosh Elementary school and was one of the first African American kid to get honor roll. July 25, 1946 Emmett aka “Bobo” was diagnosed with Polio at the age of five but Emmett managed to have a full recovery by the age of eight. August 1955 Emmett’s uncle Moses Wright from Money, Mississippi came to visit his sister Mamie Till and Emmett, Moses and Emmett
The two white men later openly confessed to Emmett Till’s brutal murder knowing that they could not be tried for the same law according to the Constitution of the United States. The inequality that existed deep in the South and all around the world towards African Americans was about to come to an undeniable halt. This is because of the injustices and racial discrimination that were evident in the Emmett Till murder and aftermath of his trial. The political injustice would soon be served and never forgotten as the Civil Rights Movement
Tom Robinson, an innocent, black man, is convicted for rape of Mayella Ewell by a jury made up of white men. Tom is setup to fail from the very beginning since it is his word against the word of of a white girl. In any court case, “when it’s a white man’s word against a black man’s, the white man always wins” (Lee 295). The jury is able to make their decision about the case just by looking at the color of Tom’s skin. Even his exceptional lawyer, Atticus Finch, is unable to convince the jury that he is not the guilty one.
The white men would always win. “Judge Taylor was pulling the jury; “Guilty...Guilty... Guilty...Guilty” Tom Robinson was convicted for a crime that he didn’t even do. They even had evidence but they still chose the white man. “Link that but might go to the chair, but he’s not going til the truth is told and you know what the truth is.”
With all the evidence given about Emmett’s murder, the verdict from the jury was that Bryant and Milam were not guilty. The jury was unjustified and unfair, and definitely not a jury of any of Till’s peers. But if same actions were have to have taken place, and if Emmett Till was anything but black, he might still be alive
A couple of months later, Bryant and Milian admitted that they committed the crime during a magazine interview for which they got paid. Since the Double Jeopardy laws was in place, the men could not be tried twice for the murder (Bio). The trial was unfair because there was only white men in the jury, the courts said they were unable to identify Till's body, but they found the body with his ring with the initials on it, in addition there was an eye witness, Till's uncle Moses Wright who testified against Milian and Roy. This murder played a big part in the African Civil Rights Movement (Osborne). A little black boy lost his life for speaking to a white woman.
Despite these facts, and the fact that MayElla Ewell basically admitted to perjury, Tom Robinson was still convicted and later murdered brutally in the same way that Rodney King was beat brutally. Ultimately, black-white trials were a series of back and forth situations, he-said-she-said encounters, whose word is more valuable than the other paradoxes. And whether or not an African American individual being tried with a crime was actually guilty, if they were put up against a white person, their word would automatically be unavailing (or futile) in comparison. No matter what they said, they were still black and that was enough for most juries to
To Kill a Mockingbird, Harper Lee Hadrien Olinger Newspaper Article Report on the death of Tom Robinson Maycomb country Tom Robinson, accused of rape People involved in this trial: Atticus Finch, lawyer of Tom Robinson Mayella Violet Ewell (19) - says she got raped Judge Taylor- the judge Mr Gilmer- lawyer of Mayella Ewell Tom Robinson (27)- accused of rape Tom Robinson gets shot dead a few hours after his trial. Had no hope left in him and decided to go for the run. He was accused of raping a white girl.
Most of black people of Maycomb in the 1930swere terrorized of committing some crime because they could be lynched for a crime they did not commit or do. One example of the book in chapter 18 was the start of the trial of Tom Robinson who was accused of rape and was in fear of being lynched for a crime he did not do. The main meaning of to Kill a Mocking Bird is to show how black people were being thought of as non-human simply because of their skin color. Tom Robinson’s trial began at chapter 18 and he feared of being lynched. He was accused by Bob Ewell because his daughter told him the Tom Robinson was the one who raped her.