When Ellie Weisel says “Indifference, then, is not only a sin it is a punishment” he makes a powerful claim about human nature. An example of this is the Nazi invasion of Europe, where many countries did not stop the Nazis from murdering the Jewish people. They chose to remain silent because they were scared of the Nazis fighting back. When faced with opposition it is better to speak up than show indifference and stay silent. In the poem The First Came by Martin Niemöller he says that if you stay silent when bad things happen then when danger comes to you it will be too late. In this poem Martin talks about how he ignored everything the bad people were doing. He ignored what they were doing to the communists, socialists, unionists and Jews. …show more content…
The indifference and the United Government staying silent took so many innocent Jewish people away from the safety of the United States. This ship was turned back after Kristallnacht or the night of broken glass. Since this event was after the night of broken glass the United States and President Roosevelt were aware what would happen if the ship was sent back. When the ship went back to Nazi Germany the Jewish people were put in concentration camps where many of them likely died. Ellie says “Rosevent was a good man, he understood those people needed help.” Rosevent could have let the ship into the United States, but he did not because he was scared of getting in a war with the Nazis. The main idea to take away from this is that Rosevelt stayed silent causing people to …show more content…
Montag had over twenty book in the grill of his air conditioner that if found will get him arrested and the Fire Department would burn them. Montag says to Mildred that they are now in this together and how he was sorry. Montag was scared to speed up because he was afraid of the Fire department burning his collection of books and him losing his job. Many positive things do happen as a result of of Montag speaking up and not staying silent. One of the main things that get better is Montag and Mildred are spending more time together and are closer to each other that then they have been in the rest of the story. Montag even say reading the books could stop Mildred from overdosing on sleeping pills so much and make her a better
The reader is able to feel empathy for the passengers, and the German U boat Captain. It is really a great experience for the
Wiesel pinpoints the indifference of humans as the real enemy, causing further suffering and lost to those already in peril. Wiesel commenced the speech with an interesting attention getter: a story about a young Jewish from a small town that was at the end of war liberated from Nazi rule by American soldiers. This young boy was in fact himself. The first-hand experience of cruelty gave him credibility in discussing the dangers of indifference; he was a victim himself.
During the scene where Montag confronts Mildred, asking her if her "family" and the "white clown" truly love her, Mildred tells Montag "Why'd you ask a silly question like that?",(Bradbury 73) because whether or not the parlor walls truly love her, at the end of the day she is happy and entertained. Montag realizes that he lost Mildred to the parlor walls and begins to accept that. In losing the one person he loves, he uses books and stories to fill his time. Despite this, Montag doesn’t drown himself in the words on the page to keep entertained, but uses the knowledge to improve upon himself and learn more. This shows that, not always do you have to take initiative for change to happen, it can happen on its own with no regards for you or others.
In the very start of the book it talks about Mildred having a mental problem that causes her to forget what she does. In the beginning of the book, Montag walks into the bedroom
This inaction by The United States government is indifference directly supporting injustice. The United States eventually became one of the allied powers and helped put an end to WW2, but for a time, they did not do anything. They helped continue the suffering of those Jewish Homo Sapiens. The action eventually provoked by this injustice was the result of information. The news of what was happening to the Jews eventually spread to enough people who were not indifferent to the suffering resulting from oppression, those who valued human life more than the fragile economy that results from war.
Holocaust survivor and author, Elie Wiesel in his thought-provoking speech, The Perils of Indifference, maintains the idea that indifference is dangerous and inhuman. He develops his message through the use of imagery, rhetorical questions, and anecdotes. Wiesel’s purpose is to warn readers of the danger that comes with indifference in order to instill a sense of urgency in the readers so that they can avoid indifference. He establishes a serious yet hopeful tone for readers by using stylistic devices such as imagery, metaphor, and rhetorical questions in order to develop his message that indifference is the most dangerous and inhuman thing known to man.
Helping the enemy People only care about themselves! It is not their problem if six million people of a group are murdered, right? Elie Wiesel, a survivor of the holocaust, the systematic murder of over six million Jews, wrote a speech about the dangers of indifference. Indifference is not caring and according to Elie Wiesel, it is the opposite of love and worse than hate. In “The Perils of Indifference” by Elie Wiesel, he uses his experiences, logic and points made from rhetorical questions to persuade his audience about how one should act when they see injustice.
Indifference can be defined as the lack of sympathy or concern for others. More importantly, it is the active decision by many to not speak up against wrong doings. This makes crises last longer and do more harm because of people not speaking up. For example, Syria’s education is struggling, especially with wartime and the violence surrounding the children. In the text “Generation missing out on school in wartime Syria '', it states, “Experts say that puts a whole generation of Syrians at risk of coming of age illiterate, lost to a war that has killed some 140,000 people already.
In this part of the book, all of the firemen including Montag received a call to burn a house with the books in there. Here became the turning point for Montag as he saw the woman, who already had made her decision to die rather than live in a world of oppression and restricted freedom of thought which books symbolize in this part, burns with the illegal books in the burning house, refusing to go out without the assurance of the safety of the books. We can suppose that his perception is gradually changing through the phrase showing that Montag felt a huge guilt over this, unlike the other firemen or Beatty. Furthermore, during the conversation with his wife, Mildred, Montag says, “We burn a thousand books. We burnt a woman.
People chose to normalize or forget it happened, continuing life as normal without a second thought, rather than try to stop or speak out against the Nazis. Martin Niemoller describes what it’s like struggling to speak out against the Nazis in “First They Came for the Communists.” He wanted to live, so he “did not speak out,” which led to his eventual capture as there was “no one left to speak out” (Niemöller 184). While it’s evident that many were afraid of their own capture, their lack of confidence to speak against the Nazis led to many people’s death. Had more people spoken out, many lives would have been saved.
In his influential 1999 speech, “Perils of Indifference,” Elie Weisel brought attention to the problem of indifference in society, and in the government. After his experiences as a child survivor of the Holocaust, he believed people were indifferent toward the dilemmas of others and chose to not care to help them, for their own sake. In his speech, he recalls historical events to prove how much the world has been affected by the dangers of indifference and forces his audience to self-reflect on this issue by asking rhetorical questions, introducing them to different points of view, and showing its effects. With this, he makes a call to action and with hope, inspires his audience to make a change. As history keeps changing, it is important
She talks about unusual things and makes Montag realize that he is not happy, changing his outlook on life. His wife, Mildred, tries to end her own life by overdosing on sleeping pills, but when she is rushed to the hospital, the doctors don’t see it as a big deal due to them seeing suicide attempts so often. All these things help Montag
Firstly, Montag stole a book to try and discover what he is missing not reading them. Clarisse at random asked Montag if he was happy, and it had never came across to Montag if he was happy. People in their society really didn't feel at all. The old woman that had rather die with her books than give them up, began to make Montag curious on why they were so special. He began to question every aspect in his life, when he does, Mildred tells Montag he should have thought before becoming a fireman.
Holocaust. Death. Suffering. These are but a few of the words that may begin to describe this tragic period in the history of man. The Perils of Indifference and Night are both publications by the Elie Wiesel, one of the many victims to the Holocaust, but one of the very few victims who lived to tell his story.
This is until the day he meets Clarisse, who looks at the world in a different way than anyone else. Then, shortly after, he has to burn down a house full of books and burn the woman inside also because she refuses to leave. This causes Montag to realize that books should not be burned and have great significance in the world. He then shows his wife the abundance of books that he has collected from his job, and his wife, Mildred, becomes concerned. This later causes her to make up lies to cover the fact that Montag is breaking the law of owning books.