Google made me stupid because I googled all the test answers and failed my test. Nicholas Carr, an American author, wrote “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” published in 2008 in The Atlantic, and he argues about the effects of the Internet on literacy, cognition, and culture. Carr starts his argument by taking an ending scene from a movie called A Space Odyssey. Carr uses logos throughout the whole essay, but also gives himself credibility by giving evidence that he knows what is going on in his mind. I feel that this argument is effective. In his article, Nicholas Carr first sets the stage by describing how the movie A Space Odyssey began and how the actor Bowman, who had nearly been sent to a deep-space death by the malfunctioning machine, is …show more content…
Some of these sources include, “I think I know what’s going on. For more than a decade now, I’ve been spending a lot of time online, searching and surfing and sometimes adding to the great databases of the Internet.” (Car. 736). He then continued in saying “Research that used to require days in the stacks or periodical rooms of libraries can now be done in minutes.” Citing these sources encourages Carr’s credibility by showing that he has done his work and supplied beliefs and aspirations, as well as an expert opinion to maintain hiser claim. He also uses personal examples from his own life to support the matter, which shows that he has a personal connection and a first-hand experience with this …show more content…
He points out facts about the human brain: “The human brain is almost infinitely malleable. People used to think that our mental meshwork, the dense connections formed among the 100 billion or so neurons inside our skulls, was largely fixed by the time we reached adulthood.” These facts support the idea that Carr’s brain is easily influenced. He then goes on to say, “But brain researchers have discovered that that’s not the case. James Olds, a professor of neuroscience who directs the Krasnow Institute for Advanced Study at George Mason University, says that even the adult mind “is very
In the article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Nicolas Carr analyzes the dramatic affects that technologies have been having on our brains. The short summary, the Net is making us all mindless zombies in Carr’s mind, but he is not the only who feels that way. His long dragged out article is abundantly full of meaning examples, personal opinions, and hard facts on the drastic changes the Net has done to our brains. Carr starts his articles with the death of super computer, HAL, from the movie A Space Odyssey.
Everyday millions of people across the globe use the internet; many never even leave the computer desk. In the article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid” the author Nicholas Carr, brings up the point that our brains are losing their attention span. He explained that many, including himself, are finding it harder to read long groups of text and articles. Though Carr brings up a good point, his argument lacked factual information, was a little dull, contained next to no credible sources, and is all over the board with he’s ideas, all of these things made his argument weak. Carr’s opening paragraph really grabs your attention, by using quotes from the movie A Space Odyssey by Stanley Kubrick’s.
In Nicholas Carr’s writing, “Is Google Making Us Stupid,” mentions multiple examples of why the internet and the simplicity of looking up and getting exactly what we were looking for are causing a drop in the way we think and the intelligence of our minds. Carr explains that he was once a huge reader and could comprehend ten to fifteen-page articles easily, but the directness of the internet had dulled his brain that he could not read a few paragraphs before he gave up and his mind started drifting off into the emptiness of his brain. Carr mentions that the Net is being the universal medium causing information that is read and learned go in one ear and out the other. Carr defends his positions by adding multiple examples showing that the Net
Nicolas Carr writes in his essay ‘a few Google searches, some quick clicks on hyperlinks, and I've got the telltale fact or pithy quote I was after'. Mr. Carr is telling us know that we no longer have to go to a library, spend hours going through card catalogs, or haul piles of books to the table in order to search through thousands of pages of text to find the information we are in search of. Instead, we have places online like Google, Yahoo, and Bing which allow us to sit back and literally, at our fingertips, have any and all information humanly possible on the ready. The days of going through an index in an encyclopedia book, sitting in front of a card catalog, or microfiche are days of the past, extinct if you will. Mr. Carr also writes 'my mind now expects to take in information the way the
Nicholas Carr’s article titled Is Google Making us Stupid was written to deliver an urgent message to the reader. Carr’s purpose for writing this article was to inform the masses of the potential dangers in how new technologies change the ways our minds work. He is trying to warn us how writing has reduced our capability to remember details in our heads, just like the internet has been able to change the way our brains store, acquire, and handle information. The author makes the argument that Carr makes a reference to the movie 2001 A Space Odyssey. In his reference he tells the reader about the HAL computer who uncannily perfectly expresses human emotion, as it shares its concern that its data banks and artificial brain is being shut down
Summary of "Is Google Making Us Stupid" by Nicholas Carr The internet has become a necessity for many people these days, it provides quick information and is a primary source of knowledge. In the article, "Is Google Making Us Stupid", the author Nicholas Carr, is describing the effects that technology has on the human brain. Carr begins with a scene from the end of Stanley Kubrick's 2001: A Space Odyssey, where supercomputer HAL is being disconnected by astronaut Dave Bowman who was sent to space on a deadly mission by the machine.
He provided evidence such as the plane crashes caused by computer malfunctions. As we become over dependent on computers, we lose awareness to our surroundings and the mind starts to wander. Over time, some of the skills that has been learned are forgotten because they have not been used for long periods of time. Once the computer malfunctions and renders itself useless, we start to panic and try to correct it without fully understanding the problem. For data, Carr gives data such as how the human mind works when computers are involved.
“Is Google Making Us Stupid” In “Is Google Making Us Stupid”, Nicholas Carr shows weakness in his information because he makes this an opinionated piece instead of using reliable evidence. First Carr does not support his information well, he simply states his fact and then move over it quickly. He lacks support throughout this entire article making this completely an opinionated article. Instead Carr should focus on finding evidence to support his theory.
Carr says that the internet is the reason behind this, especially for him as a writer. He states that the internet makes research much easier and it has been a “godsend to him as a writer.” He argues that internet use affects cognition and how it is becoming everything that we
Carr believes that this use of the prominent use of the internet is clearly changing the way that human’s think. In contrast, others may believe that his argument
In the passage Does the Internet Make You Dumber Carr claims that the internet yields our cognitive abilities. Although there is a lot that Carr discuses that I agree with there are some points I disagree with. The study he provided where some college students were allowed to use the internet during a lecture and the rest had to keep their laptops closed showed that students who did browse the internet did worse then those who did not. This is not just about the internet if you do anything besides pay attention in a lecture you are not going to do well.
He decided to write this article during the midterm election to help educate voters that they need to be better informed about a topic before they make a decision. Nicholas Carr, the author of “Is Google Making Us Stupid,” is an American writer
This sentence gives the reader the option to pick sides. Carr isn’t telling them to believe what he does but instead gives his evidence and tells the reader to form their own opinion, which is the opposite of what Google is trying to convey. After his statement, he adds that perhaps “Luddites or nostalgists will be proved correct, and from our hypertensive, data-stroked minds will spring a golden age of intellectual discovery.” Making a point for the other side shows the completeness of Carr’s understanding of the topic he is writing about. He reinforces his argument by saying “although it may replace the printing press, it produces something altogether” and continuing his claim on how the Net harms the
Carr expresses that his mind and how he thinks changed due to the new phenomenon “the Internet.” He proves his point by explaining that the internet has reprogrammed our minds to want everything quick and complete. To me, this was effective because once the reader thinks about it, they start realizing how accurate this actually is. By successfully, including pathos he interacts with the any type of audience and has them mentally
Carr believes that we depend on the Internet more than just looking up the answers in the book ourselves. He is trying to prove that our generation is consumed by the Internet. In addition to this, I feel his argument is effective because he builds credibility with personal facts, using statistics, and making emotional appeals throughout the essay. He gives many details and examples to backup and support his argument. Nicholas Carr gives himself credibility by stating that he knows what’s going on in his own mind, this is where he is uses ethos.