Section 1: Identification and evaluation of sources
The research question that is being investigated is: To what extent does the historical representation of the motion picture Schindler’s List best influence public views on the Holocaust, through the use of different narrative techniques? This particular investigation will explore the strategies used to recreate one of the most terrifying moments in history through film. Steven Spielberg, the director of the film was able to tell an engaging and seemingly authentic story while maintaining realism. Spielberg's ability to tell the story of the infamous Oskar Schindler, who saved a lot of innocent lives, while prompting real emotions in the audience is the basis of this investigation. How he was able
…show more content…
The origin of this source is valuable because Classen specializes in politics and in this article he comprehensively discuss how the film has a perfect balance of history, culture, and politics, which aids in the story telling. He says that “Schindler’s List, is the first authentic film about the Holocaust,” he also states that “nothing can top it” (Classen, Christoph 78). The purpose of this article was to explore how fictional films achieve historical truth and authenticity (Classen, Abstract) when telling a historical story. He specifically mentions the strategies Spielberg used when creating this film. This particular article is filled with opinions from a diverse group of people, it possesses valuable points, but it cannot be heavily relied. Contrasting perspectives are addressed, not all in great detail, but there weren't any forced facts or strong opinions. Overall this article does well in hitting important points, and there’s an acceptable balance of bias and
The Holocaust is the title utilized to the systematic state-sponsored persecution and genocide of the Jews of Europe and North Africa along with other organizations throughout World War II via Nazi Germany and collaborators. " Early factors of the Holocaust consist of the Kristallnacht pogrom of the 8th and 9th November 1938 and the T-4 Euthanasia Program", progressing to the later use of killing squads and extermination camps in a large and centrally equipped effort to exterminate each and every viable member of the populations focused by means of the Nazis. The Jews of Europe were the main victims of the Holocaust in what the Nazis called the "Final Solution of the Jewish Question". The often used discern for the range of Jewish victims is six million, so a whole lot so that the phrase "six million" it is almost universally interpreted as referring to the Jewish victims of the Holocaust. Even though estimates by historians using, amongst different sources, records from the Nazi regime itself, range from 5 million to seven million (Duiker et al.
The Holocaust was an absolutely devastating time period, killing over 6 million innocent Jewish people. Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel lived through the tortuous time and wrote a meaningful memoir called Night. He also made a visit to Auschwitz, a concentration camp he stayed at. The visit to Auschwitz was made into a moving documentary called “Winfrey & Wiesel:Auschwitz”. A memoir and a documentary are both ways to convey and expose the events of the Holocaust and their severity.
Different Views of the Holocaust Portrayed Through Various Literary Elements “Life is a matter of perspective. It can be amazing or wonderful, or it can be depressing and worthless” (Gray, n.d.). This quote from Stephen Gray exemplifies both aspects of life in according to how one perceives it. As a result, some people choose to see life negatively instead of focusing on the positive aspects that make life great. In Elie Wiesel’s (2006) book Night and the movie “Life is Beautiful” (2000), there are two different aspects of how life is viewed while enduring struggling circumstances.
Director Jackson said the film was timely because it was about fighting for truth. The plot of this film is when Deborah Lipstadt, a professor of Holocaust studies introduced her book, “Denying the Holocaust: The Growing Assault on Truth and Memory” And then David Irving interrupted her and he’s offering $1,000 in cash to anyone in the audience who can prove Hitler ordered the Holocaust because he is totally against that Adolf Hitler is bad all the time. David Irving files a libel lawsuit in the UK against her and her publisher for declaring him a Holocaust Denier in her books.
After watching the documentary I think you really get a sense of how horrific the Holocaust was. I mean we always learn about it in school, but it is usually through textbooks and primary source documents. We learn about the atrocities; however the American educational system touches upon it lightly. Ultimately, Americans only get a small idea of what the Holocaust was especially to the Jewish people. We learn so much about the Holocaust, but not about who lived by it.
The Holocaust took place during the years 1933 to 1945. It was an attempt to remove all of the Jews, and other smaller groups such as homosexuals and Jehovah's Witnesses, which lived in the country of Germany. The events that took place during the holocaust were lead by a German man named Adolf Hitler. Schindler's List is a film about the Holocaust from a man named Oskar Schindler's perspective as a leader of a concentration camp. The film displays the five stages of the Holocaust.
Though there are many differences and variations in sources from the Holocaust, whether it be Night written by Elie Wiesel, Life is Beautiful directed by Roberto Benigni, or multiple accounts from Holocaust survivors from an article called Tales from Auschwitz by The Guardian, they all will agree that it was a terrible and unforgivable atrocity committed not only to the Jewish people, but all of mankind. One similarity that the three sources share, as baffling and terrifying as it
This excerpt is taken from Gale Opposing Viewpoints In Context, a premier online resource database, covering pro/con arguments for many of today’s important social issues. The authors contributing to this viewpoint are Motoko Rich and John Broder, contributing writers from the New York Times. This source can be deemed credible and reliable since the New York Times is an institution when it comes to honest reporting. Although this is an older source (2011), the topic presented in this article remains relevant in our society today. This source remains very neutral and presents viewpoints from both sides of the argument.
Both Steven Spielberg’s Schindler’s list and Polanski’s The Pianist have impacted society understanding of the Holocaust and the unjust treatment of the Jews, not to mention the ungodly acts of the Nazi’s towards the Jewish community. In particular Steven Spielberg’s Schindler’s List disregarded the social norms of film in the 90’s, approaching a sensitive topic head, disregarding numerous request not, synthesising a film illustrating the actions of Oskar Schindler. Winning seven academy awards, Schindler’s List transformed the education system, instigating the change of the curriculum in the United States from The Holocaust being a minor aspect of World War 2, to teachers educating students about the bleak history of The Holocaust, using The
For instance, Anne Frank overheard on the English radio that friends were being taken away. In Source A, she asked herself, “If it 's that bad in Holland, what must it be like in those faraway and uncivilized places where the Germans are sending them? We assume that most of them are being murdered.” In other words, Jewish people who listened to the English radio felt threatened and apprehensive, because the government was leading them to make assumptions of horrible conditions friends and family may be in. Similarly, the eight steps of genocide illustrate how the government’s actions affect the Nazis view of the Jewish people, by making them seem different and out of place.
Throughout Schindler’s List by Steven Spielberg, Oskar Schindler’s character has changed drastically. At the beginning of World War II, Schindler was a womanizing, selfish and manipulative man. After seeing the process that he watched the Jews go through, he realizes the way the Nazis have treated them is unacceptable. Towards the end of the war Schindler has grown due to the experiences he has been through. These experiences have made him a decent, unselfish, and manipulative man.
Helen's story is memorable, as is the plight of young Danka Dresner and her mother as they strive to avoid death while staying together. There's a Jewish couple that marries in the Plaszow camp, even though their chances of survival are dim, and a Rabbi who survives a close encounter with a Nazi gun. Of course the Holocaust images are grim, but scenes of mass graves and exhumed bodies are not unique to Schindler's List. While it's impossible to deny their power, potentially more disturbing are the instances of callous, individual murder. Spielberg doesn't spare his audience when it comes to sudden violence or the dehumanizing factors involved in such events.
Some argue the idea that before Schindler’s List, his films like the Color Purple and Empire of the Sun which were serious films but some claim that the films were flawed in an attempt to maked the holocaust seem “more dramatic”. (Welsh The idea of this is absolutely false it is absurd and frankly sick to think that one would make one of the biggest human genocides “more dramatic” Others argue the reason that before Schindler’s list, Spielberg was a totally different actor. One film critic who reviewed the Sugarland Express, called Spielberg a “ commercial and shallow and impersonal. They called out the idea that Spielberg was more about marketing than the actual film. (Manchel 26).
It came with its pros and cons just as anything else. The New York Times covered this breaking news with a strong approach. The Times kept their bias out of this article which is always a pro. It is always preferred that bias is left out so the reader can create their own opinion on the topic presented. The points presented are thought provoking for sure.
People to this day still find horror and beauty in this film, finding this film an extraordinary masterpiece executed by director, Steven Spielberg. Some people do disagree with the images shown in the film, however, as a whole, the entire community who thoroughly enjoys films agree the accuracy of this film that did not hold back any viewing content truly added greatly to the film. Perhaps the most touching reaction came from the place where it all started. The premiere of Schindler’s List in Germany with a room filled with 800 people – Germans and Jews, diplomats and artists, film makers and people who had known Oskar Schindler when he lived there (Whitney, 1994).