When Hollywood is formulating a way to adapt history into a film, its accuracies and inaccuracies must be considered. The film Glory tells the heroic tale of the 54th Massachusetts Infantry Regiment, starting with its formation and concluding with the assault on Fort Wagner near Charleston, South Carolina. However, Hollywood romanticizes history in order to influence the viewer’s perception of historical events. The scholarship that has been read in class and the film Glory show the continued prejudice against African American soldiers, prevalence and significance of death and burial, and the immorality that war causes. The film contains many narrated letters from Captain Robert Gould Shaw to his family to inform them of the progress of the war. Before the Battle of Antietam, Shaw writes that, …show more content…
Downs wrote, “there were no general hospitals, when the war began, and ‘hospitals had to be improvised, in hotels, halls, and other unsuitable buildings.’”3 The focus of both Union and Confederate governments and officials were not on medical and health concerns, making the casualties of battle more dire, as “no one was prepared to treat the hundreds of soldiers who were severely wounded, nor were they prepared to bury the dead bodies… the military lacked the infrastructure and manpower necessary to reduce many of the dying and wounded.”4 The few scenes that involve injury and medical assistance do not reflect the extent to which there was a lack of medical infrastructure in place during the war, nor does it show the illness that plagued camps. Overall, the problems of medicine and illness were not addressed in the film, and when they were, they were not portrayed in a way that was consistent with Jim Downs’
Paine’s words might increase the army’s population and inspire many men to actually work in the army. When the Continental army finds their way through the “crisis” they would have successfully tested their beliefs and
This is were Glory begins the movie depicts the story through Shaw’s eyes from the battle of Antietam where Shaw is dumb founded by the horror of war, now this is a tad bit of a history let off because he would have already seen combat casualties in the 1st battle of Winchester where there were huge casualties
The United States Civil War is possible one of the most meaningful, bloodstained and controversial war fought in American history. Northern Americans against Southern Americans fought against one another for a variety of motives. These motives aroused from a wide range of ideologies that stirred around the states. In James M. McPherson’s What they fought for: 1861-1865, he analyzes the Union and Confederate soldier’s morale and ideological components through the letters they wrote to love ones while at war. While, John WhiteClay Chambers and G. Kurt Piehler depict Civil War soldiers through their letters detailing the agonizing battles of war in Major Problems in American Military History.
Infections, like trench foot, were common during the civil war because there were no antibiotics, surgical instruments were never washed, and hospitals were very unhygienic. Doctors, surgeons, and nurses had very little knowledge of how disease and infection spread. Since there were no antibiotics, the most common solution for infections were amputations. If you did not have the limb amputated, normally you would die. So, it was either death or absence of a limb, which one would you
The influence of Hollywood can be seen increasing or decreasing the public’s perception of a person, group, or cause in the matter of moments. John Wayne is one that can be argued to have had am extremely large impact on the creation/influence of war films through personal views. In Allan Dwan’s film Sands of Iwo Jima, the most expensive film to date, he we give John Wayne the nod for the lead role of Sergeant Srkyer, whose job was to lead a group of inexperienced Marines into Iwo Jima. This would be Wayne’s first Academy Award nomination, thus solidifying his emerging influence in Hollywood. Though John Wayne had no military experience whatsoever, his political beliefs, and his portrayal of an American within his films helped him gain support from high national figures.
Tillman, in Army fatigues, sits in a tree with an assault rifle in hand, waiting for someone to test his shooting skills. The landscape behind him is brown and looks dead and lifeless, just like his fallen comrades.one feels Tillman’s demeanor in the photograph, but whether he is focused on the seriousness of war or the fear of imminent death we will never know (SI “Remember” n. pag.). To appeal to their audience, this cover uses specific tactics. The fatigues induce a sense of patriotism that hits home with the American audience.
Life for the Union Soldier was not only brutal on the battlefield, but the camp life for a Union soldier was just as cruel. With the lack of personal hygiene, unsavory and repugnant food, and the shortage of clothing made living, a very difficult thing to do. Growth in the number of people with diseases was also a contributing factor to the massive amounts of death within the camp and as well as the post-battle wounds that often left either a man with one less limb or put in a mental institution. A Union Soldier’s life during the Civil War was cruel and horrific during their stay at the camps.
Should I Stay or Should I Go It was freezing, feet and hands numb, stomach growling at me like a bear. I needed to leave. It was 1777, George Washington and his troops arrived at Valley Forge. It was “1 mile away from Pennsylvania” (Background Essay) and nowhere to really go, and no one really wanted to go.
Inspect, stamp, repeat. Looking around the room, young men fill the chairs and benches inside the Confederate Army sign-up post. As the next man approaches my desk he extends his application papers. Peering over the top of the application, I learn his name is Jackson Campbell. Appearing no wider than a floorboard and unable to carry more than 50 pounds, Jackson’s chances of becoming a soldier declince with every word.
The Civil War was filled with many diseases and deaths. Over 620,000 men lost their lives during this war; roughly two thirds of the casualties were caused by the lack of medical knowledge of many diseases. The remaining one third of the casualties was from the actual battle itself. The war became a turning point for many women interested in the medical field. The knowledge of medicine was the beginning of a new age during the Civil War, and the lack of it led to many gruesome deaths.
Do you ever contemplate about what it would be like to be in combat in the Civil War because if so readers can get a good outlook of what it would be like to fight on the union side in both of these books The Red Badge of Courage and the Soldier’s Heart. In this essay one will be contrasting the two stories mentioned earlier. As well in this essay one will be comparing these two very informational and exciting stories about the civil war and the characters as well as how ironically the two characters have very many resemblances. While reading this essay one comprehends the two stories similarities and differences, also the reader will acquire knowledge about how the main characters in both of the stories have very similar points of view. There are very few differences between the stories Red Badge of Courage and Soldier’s Heart here are a few just to show how little they have in differences.
The opportunity was given to Shaw to lead the first ever all negro repentant the 54th Massachusetts. COl. War changes people, as exemplified by the characters in the movie Glory. The trials and tribulations of fighting the enemy can change even the hardest of hearts. Colonel Shaw in the movie Glory perspective changed tremendously throughout the movie.
While the effort of America was important in winning the war, there was a lot of discrimination and prejudice against blacks, Native Americans, women, and homosexuals within the military. The men who fought in the war saw terrible conditions and many had mental breakdowns. This chapter in the book explains the deaths that many soldiers witnessed and how many men became separated from humanity. This caused many soldiers to become insane. The final two chapters in the book talk about changes in the American society throughout the war and the results from the war.
Portrayal of Soldiers The portrayal of soldiers in texts shapes the way the general public see soldiers, even if the way they’re being portrayed is inaccurate. In this connections report I will be using examples from four texts: “Saving Private Ryan” directed by Steven Spielberg, “Kelly’s Heroes” directed by Brian G. Hutton, “Iraq And Roll” written and performed by Clint Black and “Hacksaw Ridge” directed by Mel Gibson. Not all soldiers are patriotic The creators of soldier related texts often depict their characters as loyal, patriotic and happy to follow orders, but some creators want to show that not everyone has a perfect moral compass.
The movie Saving Private Ryan contradicts Hollywood’s perspective of war being something that is viewed as valiant, heroic, and admirable for the audiences. Instead it draws elements of grueling severity, vigorous realism, and demoralizing codification, making Saving Private Ryan a film that resonates with audiences not only in an impactful way, but also meant to bring about awareness during World War II’s depressing events and tragedies. Steven Speilberg created the movie in 1998 and set it during the events of WWII, where Speilberg is known for similar works such as Schindler’s List and The Last Days. The plot focuses on Captain Miller, a simple English teacher born in Pennsylvania, and his unit of average war soldiers. The writer of the